Smallies are tough for me to judge. Northern versions of them look like 6-7 pounders to me but may be only 3-4 pounders. I have a set of digital scales but we couldn't find them to save our life. I still haven't found them. If I would have been thinking I could have got a length and girth measurement and got close to the weight but my wife was rushing me to get pictures. She didn't want to kill it and wanted to get it back in the water asap. We were thinking around 5 lbs but everybody says it looks bigger. I personally think 5 is about right.