The Amish I know and deal with would not considered him amish or associate with this guy. They will not allow pictures to be taken of them or their animals. They don't want to be individualized.
when I was a kid, we had a gobbler come into our yard to strut around our domestic turkeys. I waited until he had his fan up,and his view to the rear blocked, and snuck in behind him. It took me about 15 minutes of starting and stopping, but I got to within 5 yards of him. He was shocked when he dropped his fan and I was standing right behind him.