I always enjoyed Catmans posts. I think we all overthink it. We have deer populations in places that are just unhealthy, especially in the urban/suburban areas. If the hunter is killing and not wasting the meat then I have no qualms with it. With the decrease in hunters over the past decade or so and not on utilizing the reason to hunt, to have a great source of meat, I don't see how if someone is going after game in a legal manner are we to judge. I hunt for meat for the table and to help control what little I do the over dense population even in my rural area. Again my input isn't worth anything probably.