Close Calls with Mistaken Identity?

woodsman87

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2012
Messages
1,560
Reaction score
1
Location
south TN
Turkey hunting is a dangerous sport that is for sure. I have never had an experience anywhere close to that. Just run-ins with other rude hunters on public and private lands.

Safety is the main issue I have with decoys. There are a lot of fools out there that would just go and start shooting anything that looks like a turkey. Heck, just because rifles and road hunting are illegal doesn't mean some guy could go driving down the road with a case of bud and the "ought-six" and shoot at your decoy. It is scary.
 
Amazingly and thankfully I've never had any close call with regards to getting shot or vice versa.

I've had more than a couple of heated run ins with idiots as all I hunt here is public land. The rudeness of other hunters never ceases to amaze me, and they quickly find out that I'm not the person to jerk around when it comes to turkeys.

I hope to remain safe on both ends for the remainder of my life, but it is always in the back of my head
 
I was hunting Obion River WMA when I was in college walking along mid-morning calling trying to strike a bird. I stopped and called and two birds answered me 200 hundred yards away. I moved quickly towards them in a low area and 50 yards into my move, there was a 7 foot tall levee. I called again and the turkeys hammered at what I guessed to be 75 yards away and on the other side of the bank I started the slowly belly crawl up the bank. I was just going to lay prone and peer over the top and wait for them to show up. Just as I got to the top and started to peer over, someone shot within 15 yards of me. I jumped back and rolled down the bank trying to figure out what happened. I climbed back to the top and looked over and saw a guy standing on a turkey's neck next to two hen decoys and a strutter decoy with a real fan (in pretty thick woods mind you) just on the other side. The guy had been set up in that spot all morning and I just happened to strike those turkeys and call them right into his decoy spread. Had I peered over the bank a little earlier, I would have been looking at a strutting turkey decoy in the exact spot I had just heard real turkeys gobble. I like to think I would have known it wasn't real, but I could see how a decoy would get shot like that.
 
I never have had a "close call" but Wildcat and I were hunting at LBL one year and had a guy sneak in on us.

He popped out into the field about 50 yards from us on the right hand edge of the field.
The lay of the land allowed only a lower sternum to top of head view of him as he stood there.

I was AMAZED at how the mossy oak break-up, his black hair and beard looked like a turkey in full strut!!!

I mean I got the fast heartbeat and everything. I just KNEW it was a turkey in full strut standing there.

I still say if you make sure to actually SEE beard before you pull the trigger there would never be an accident.

It was amazing at the distance what I "THOUGHT" I was seeing.
 
Poser said:
SCN's post about turkey hunting becoming the most accident prone form of hunting in Tennessee (largely due to mistaken identity) got me to thinking: Who has had close calls with mistaken identity?

2 years ago, I was hunting the Shelby Forest quota hunt. I was way out in the middle of the slough -probably the farthest point you can get from a road in all of SF. I had 2 gobblers and hens land in front of me just out of range (45-50 yards), hang around for awhile and then head off. I decided to go after them and try to cut them off. I did a big circle at a half running pace in the direction I figured they would head due to be cutting off by a large swamp. I set up in a well concealed position tucked under a cypress tree. A few minutes later, I see movement through thick underbrush. I see two red heads floating along at turkey head height about 25 yards away and looks like they are going to pop out in the open at one particular spot. I flick my safety off and reposition my barrel. Out of the brush, busts two guys wearing red hats and sporting fishing gear. I later determined they had been walking in a dry slough bed which made their red hats appear they were turkey head height.

I never had my finger on the trigger, but these two guys came out of the woods with my barrel pointed directly at them. They never noticed me. Now, note that I don't think these guys were supposed to be out there fishing and, even if they were, it would be highly unusual to see anyone fishing in a spot that remote in the mosquito infested nastiness that is SF. They had to know there were quota hunts going on, because otherwise, the gate to access the bottom would have been closed. Regardless, I felt sick at my stomach about it. Someone with less discretion could have easily shot these guys.
I know the spot well. You are correct that they should not have been in there.
 
Just happened to a guy from my area, shot his best firend with kids present. His best friend that shot him is the Chief at the local PD. Its a very sad time for both families.
 
Do you know any more details Rem? Since I first saw it done I have always thought that this dam youtube "fanning" sensations of people crawling through grass holding full strut gobbler decoys or fans in front of their faces was going to get several people killed. I wish they would make it illegal tomorrow. I can't believe people do it at all.
 
ive never had nothing real bad happen. rude people trespassers. stuff like that. turkey hunting can be very dangerous for sure. people that hunt with decoys need to be very careful especially a strutter decoy. just be careful and make sure people know how your set up. when I hunt with someone we hardly ever break from each other and we know who will shoot when etc. if we do go our separate ways we put boundaries on our self. I couldn't imagine shooting someone or getting shot. or being tied in to it period. got to be one of the worst things possible to go through.
 
REM7 said:
Just happened to a guy from my area, shot his best firend with kids present. His best friend that shot him is the Chief at the local PD. Its a very sad time for both families.
I have a post in the general forum for prayers for both families. This is a horrible case of mistaken identity.
 
Had an idiot neighbor shoot my new pretty boy decoy several years ago with me between them.After having no remorse,and having a smart mouth,lets just say it cost him blood,sweat,tears,and a new stock for his gun.
 
This morning I had been on some gobbling birds and they had follows hens away from me. I found a log to sit on and was just listening for where they were headed. I seen movement in front of me and first thought it was a strutting bird about 100 yards through the woods, but couldn't make it out other than the initial movement. I looked away for a split second and when I looked back there was a deer standing about 25 yards away. The movement I actually seen was the left ear of the deer which in my eyes was a gobbler strutting at the last spot I heard a gobble. It is easy to make things what you want them to be in the heat of the moment.
 
Lightly peppered once by a tresspasser who snuck in on a bird I was calling. It's sobering. Had several other incidents with tresspassers sneaking in on vocal birds I was working. For that reason, I actually hope the birds don't gobble too much on the roost anymore. For some reason, many more people seem to ignore property lines during turkey season than deer season. It's extremely dangerous, and honestly, I'm surprised more people don't get shot.

I'm usually guiding 3 or 4 others everytime I go into the woods, haven't hunted solo in years. I usually keep the group together, but if I feel it is necessary to split the group up, I split the property between a fence or a road and give explicit instructions that neither group is to cross the fence or road for ANY reason, nor are they allowed to shoot across the fence. We also keep tabs on one another with cell phones now.
 
Back
Top