Heavy birds this year

catman529

catman529

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2010
Messages
29,472
Reaction score
2,552
Location
Franklin TN
Many people have been posting gobblers weighing 23, 24 even 25 pounds. Mine was 23-9 which is my heaviest ever. So what's the cause, is it extra mast in the woods or what? Or did the ice freeze cold storm have anything to do with it? Either way I like how fat the birds are this year.


Sent from the talk of tap
 
First a ton of folks lie about bird weight, why I have no idea because it means nothing, but people in this state tend to grossly exaggerate the weights

But it is possible as a result of a massive acorn crop
 
My son shot one just under 23...noticed it was a big bird for our area. It was a mild fall, where they could plump up, but I hope the heavier bird weights show a healthier overall flock. I agree with Setterman that the mast crop was likely a big factor
 
I think alot of people exaggerate the weight.

I would rather kill a 16 pound adult gobbler than a 24 pounder. I believe the smaller ones have more of the true wild genes.

I have seen over 200 dead gobblers in Alabama and Tennessee combined. Biggest one was a 24 pounder killed in Giles county Tennessee. The average weights are about 19 pounds.

Sent from my Lumia 900 using Tapatalk
 
A lot of people use digital fish scales, myself included, and a lot of these birds are actually big, I don't remember people "exaggerating" about the weight this much in the past. Sure some people guess the weight but overall a lot of the turkeys posted here lately have been 2-3 pounds heavier than usual.


Sent from the talk of tap
 
Catman, agreed.
Digital scales put my jake from this weekend at 25.4 pounds. He was as long as my Mossberg 835.
But, this farm in Lincoln County (just east of Giles) has always had larger than normal birds.
 
catman529":96p41ifc said:
A lot of people use digital fish scales, myself included, and a lot of these birds are actually big, I don't remember people "exaggerating" about the weight this much in the past. Sure some people guess the weight but overall a lot of the turkeys posted here lately have been 2-3 pounds heavier than usual.


Sent from the talk of tap
Click to expand...

People lie/exaggerate like crazy. I've killed a ton of turkeys and seen a ton more and the biggest I've ever touched weighed just under 24 lbs. every bird weighs about the same except in the Deep South they're smaller

It's some sort of d*ck measuring contest when it comes to turkey weights. Which for the life of me makes no sense.
 
Setterman":2mujxen7 said:
catman529":2mujxen7 said:
A lot of people use digital fish scales, myself included, and a lot of these birds are actually big, I don't remember people "exaggerating" about the weight this much in the past. Sure some people guess the weight but overall a lot of the turkeys posted here lately have been 2-3 pounds heavier than usual.


Sent from the talk of tap
Click to expand...

People lie/exaggerate like crazy. I've killed a ton of turkeys and seen a ton more and the biggest I've ever touched weighed just under 24 lbs. every bird weighs about the same except in the Deep South they're smaller

It's some sort of d*ck measuring contest when it comes to turkey weights. Which for the life of me makes no sense.
Click to expand...
you haven't touched all the birds from all the different flocks across the state. Some people lie and exaggerate but some people are also honest. But you will probably never believe it unless you hold each bird with a certified scale and 3 witnesses.

And I'm not aware of any contest about turkey weights. Most people care about the beard and spurs. Never seen anyone here try to one-up another based on weight.


Sent from the talk of tap
 
The birds are heavier in the beginning of the season as well. Let them chase hens for 8-10 weeks and you won't find many over 20 pounds. I agree about people bragging about the weight like it has something to do with it being a better turkey. My experience has been most unusually large birds are healthy 2 year olds. My best bird weighed 16 pounds but had 1.5 razor spurs, I'll take that over a 25 pound 3/4 spur any day.
 
Buddy of mine told me that he called in one for his son Saturday that weighed THIRTY POUNDS!!. Don't think he'd lie at church on Easter morning do ya? [emoji15]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I use a Rapala digital fish scale and hang them up on it. I also hang it so it's stationary to make it more accurate. There were a ton of acorns this winter and the clover jumped up really well the last month. I was surprised how heavy the 3 we killed Saturday were. They weighed 23 7 23 14 and 24 7.

I assure you I have no reason to lie, due to the fact that I wouldn't even weigh them if it weren't required when you turn them in. We are also selective about which ones get shot, cause just like deer, I had rather kill the older ones. Also not sure why anyone would lie about it. I though the beard and spurs were for bragging purposes?

Most mature birds around here usually average about 22lbs. I just think food sources were abnormally good for them this winter. I killed one 2 years ago that weighed 28 lbs 2 oz. which likely won't ever happen again. Plus, Williamson County has good dirt. :) You also have to take into account that environments are totally different. Turkeys around here eat a lot of spilled corn and beans out of neighboring silos and eat out of creep feeders the neighbors have for calves year round.
 
RF270":2l7ufqld said:
The birds are heavier in the beginning of the season as well. Let them chase hens for 8-10 weeks and you won't find many over 20 pounds. I agree about people bragging about the weight like it has something to do with it being a better turkey. My experience has been most unusually large birds are healthy 2 year olds. My best bird weighed 16 pounds but had 1.5 razor spurs, I'll take that over a 25 pound 3/4 spur any day.
Click to expand...

I kill turkeys to eat and I can't eat a spur, and don't even keep them, so I would much rather kill a heavier bird.
 
catman529":391dk352 said:
Setterman":391dk352 said:
catman529":391dk352 said:
A lot of people use digital fish scales, myself included, and a lot of these birds are actually big, I don't remember people "exaggerating" about the weight this much in the past. Sure some people guess the weight but overall a lot of the turkeys posted here lately have been 2-3 pounds heavier than usual.


Sent from the talk of tap
Click to expand...

People lie/exaggerate like crazy. I've killed a ton of turkeys and seen a ton more and the biggest I've ever touched weighed just under 24 lbs. every bird weighs about the same except in the Deep South they're smaller

It's some sort of d*ck measuring contest when it comes to turkey weights. Which for the life of me makes no sense.
Click to expand...
you haven't touched all the birds from all the different flocks across the state. Some people lie and exaggerate but some people are also honest. But you will probably never believe it unless you hold each bird with a certified scale and 3 witnesses.

And I'm not aware of any contest about turkey weights. Most people care about the beard and spurs. Never seen anyone here try to one-up another based on weight.


Sent from the talk of tap
Click to expand...

Killed and watched them die in every conceivable part of this state, MS, Ky, AL, Ga, VA, and FL. I also talk daily with guys hunting all those same areas/states. These aren't newcomers either, they've toted one or two out over the years.

Not saying it's not possible, just saying people tend to stretch the truth
 
I have no reason to lie. I write down the weight, beard length and spur length of every bird I have killed along with the date and location. The gobbler I killed yesterday weighed 24lbs 14oz and was over 2lbs bigger than any of the others I have ever killed. On average from the last 18 or so years most of my gobblers were in the 19 to 22 pound range.
 
Roost 1":kfqyjv3c said:
Lots of corn fed birds were killed this weekend.. I love when you can clearly see in the pics or videos the bare ground where they have been feeding them......
Click to expand...

Which ones? I want to go back and look at them.
 
Fleet Fox":1hnaczyc said:
Roost 1":1hnaczyc said:
Lots of corn fed birds were killed this weekend.. I love when you can clearly see in the pics or videos the bare ground where they have been feeding them......
Click to expand...

Which ones? I want to go back and look at them.
Click to expand...

Pay close attention and you can figure it out for yourself... I'll never accuse anyone directly, but we all kno it happens...
 
Found em, and one in particular if you save it, then enlarge you can actually see corn remnants. I'll make sure it gets to the right folks 8-)
 

Latest posts

Back
Top