Matt.Wilson said:
. . . . I saw a group of gobblers come running when some jakes got into it and started fighting purr sounds. I mean, all of the gobblers came looking for a fight.
The "fighting purr" sounds are much more effective when real turkeys are making them, in large part because those coming in are VISUALLY seeing those doing the "fighting purr" sounds.
This sound/call is like most other turkey sounds & calls:
Sometimes it works, but most of the time when you use it, you can expect no more reponse that if you try to rattle up a buck with rattling antlers.
I've killed turkeys using it, but more commonly I've had a gobbler hang up out of range when he couldn't locate the turkeys doing the "fighting purrs". But most of the time, just no response whatsoever --- same can be said for most turkey calls, most of the time.
Setterman said:
I usually will throw that out as a last resort . . . . .
And usually, the results are the same as all the other turkey calls that aren't working. :grin:
I actually think the "fighting purr" may have it's best shot to work as a "first" resort, especially with a gobbler you've been unsuccessful in calling on previous days. I had one a few years ago that would always respond to my calling, but he would never get closer than about 100 yards, usually never getting closer at all, expecting the hen to come to him.
I tried to lure him in over several different days, not using decoys, using decoys, little calling, lots of calling, you name it. One morning all I did was the fighting purr, just one run for a few seconds, then I totally quit calling. Although he did not respond vocally, he did come slipping in, allowing me to take him at about 25 yards. I believe had I made any other turkey sounds (after the first) or been using a decoy, he'd have done just like all the other days before. But this day, a different call, and I suspect the
lack of subsequent calling (and the lack of a decoy) had more to do with his coming in than my using the fighting purr sounds.
I've since tried it numerous times, and yet to be able to say it worked any better than some other call. However, I do believe birds may be more likely to "hang up" on you when you use the "fighting purr", i.e. they are expecting to
SEE something --- when they don't, they hang up. Sometimes the bird comes in, sometimes he doesn't, and his situation and mood may have more to do with your results than which turkey sounds you're making.
Sometimes, just doing something different is what works.
But if you (and/or other hunters) do it more often, then it's no longer "something different".