Opinions?

[Hollar Hunter]

I believe this to be the same buck? I'm thinking he was 2.5 last year and 3.5 this year? Do y'all agree its the same deer and aged correctly? Just trying to keep as accurate a record I can on these bucks...


These are the only pics I got of him last year and they were taken in December.

[/img]

[/img]


This Year

[/img]

[/img]

[/img]

[/img]

 

[bowhunter163]

I think he could have been 3.5 last year

 

[Hollar Hunter]

I think he could have been 3.5 last year

Yea I had that thought lingering in my head to, so I thought I'd get as many opinions as I could...

 

[hitek7]

I think it is a different deer but kinda hard to be sure with the pics given.

 

[easy45]

It does have the look of the same deer, he might be a year older than what your thinking

 

[BSK]

I think it is very possibly the same buck. Many of his antler characteristics match up well.

I agree on your ages FOR NOW, but reserve the right to up them by a year after seeing that buck's picture in late October!

 

[Barnes Ridge Rambler]

I think he could have been 3.5 last year

X2

 

[catman529]

Hard to tell but great potential. Good luck with him mark

 

[Winchester]

very likely but first set of pics don't help much.

 

[WORM82]

Looks like the same scar on his left back leg where it meets his belly. I think it's the same buck

 

[Roost 1]

Same buck.....and I think you are correct on age.

 

[Boone 58]

you could be right........he looks at least 2.5 last year but may have been a 3.5 then. not sure.....but he is shooter this year!