There are problems with every forum there is. The main problem is that they have people on them. Hahah.
A.T. is full of people from all different styles of archery and filled with all age groups. Some have very very inflated egos. Some have no sense of their own likes/dislikes and will repeat everything they've heard from their dealer or buddies as the gospel truth. Some are diehard fanboys of particular products...some change bows like my wife changes pocketbooks and go through at least 5 a year. The main thing is to have a discriminating eye. That goes for any forum. The opposite is true for this particular forum. It doesn't generate enough readers/contributors during the bulk of the yr but really picks up around archery season as it pertains mostly to hunting. So this is more of strictly a hunting forum for me. Whereas I shoot yr round and spend more time in tournament setup than I do in hunting setup. That's not a bad thing...but TnDeer would be one of the last places I would post a question about setting a bow up with a target stabilizer setup, or to ask about target sights, etc. VS ArcheryTalk where you have a larger demographic of target archers...some of which have been top 5 at all the ASA shoots they've shot in this year...which is quite impressive. Brand specific forums are okay...but also have their drawbacks too. On those, you FOR SURE have the fanboy base. So if you were wanting to ask which of Brand X or Brand Z would be best...you can always expect it to be hands down, the one for the particular brand forum you are on...and you will never find negative posts/reviews on brand specific forums...they get zapped by the moderators.