Same Deer?

[monsterbuck07]

2011

Right Main beam has the same hook on end and the right side point looks the same to me.

2012

 

[Living2Hunt]

I think it is possiple, but hard to tell with those pics!

 

[ROUGH COUNTRY HUNTER]

could be

 

[Good time Charlie]

No way ..the configuration is all together different.
Deer on bottom is younger ..in my opinion

 

[monsterbuck07]

I was thinking that deer was younger also, the rack just looked very similar

 

[taximan]

the neck on the second deer looks alot smaller and his overall feature are more slim, but the first pic was takin in december and the second pic was takin during summer months so im not sure if that makes a difference...I think they are different but im no expert...

 

[Boone 58]

 

[Boone 58]

could be!!

 

[rem270]

nope

 

[ram46]

I'd say the white throat path on the first deer is smaller and it looks like a more mature deer than the second,maybe 2.5

 

[bass56]

No

 

[hitek7]

Could be, not sure. I would think the neck would be smaller when they were in velvet than just after the rut so I do not think you can judge by that. Hard to tell from those pics those? Have one of the velvet buck that is not zoomed in?