I won't go in the woods without them. I start my year in the deep south and frequently run across venomous snakes. I've had enough close calls over the years that not wearing them is insane and like driving without a seatbelt.
I've had them all, and best I can tell they all suck in their own special ways. I demand waterproof boots, and an aggressive sole since I hunt 99% of my time here on rugged steep terrain.
Rocky boots were comfy but leak after 2 weeks
Lacrosse miserable to wear but stay waterproof for about a month
Irish Setter junk not worth owning
Bass Pro see irish setter
Cabelas are okay stay waterproof a little longer but the soles are awful.
Danner Pronghorns are fair at best, but for the money they should be better. I could get them to last almost an entire season before they started leaking and the soles are solid.
I took the plunge last year and bought a pair of Russell boots. They are pricey, but so far so good. I got to choose my sole and other than one time in the snow they have done incredibly well. They didn't like the snow and my feet were wet, but how many times do we hunt turkeys in the snow?
It's a tough pill to swallow and cough up Russell $$$ for boots, but for me and what I put a pair of boots through I demand the best performance and durability from my footwear.