If I hunted him I would wait until later on when hopefully most of his hens are bred. If I truly haven't seen a turkey there in a number of years then I probably would not hunt him, especially if I had other spots to go to. But there's always a chance that another hunter could get him too.
The thing with turkeys is they move a lot, you never know how many miles he came from, and where he could end up traveling next year.
Usually in the spring time is when your chances of seeing a turkey are up, because they start moving, hens looking for nesting spots and gobblers just looking for more areas with hens.
I own a small farm in Giles county, and there are never ever turkeys on it except for months mid March through July. Partly because the southern end of Giles county in my area population densities are poor, and partly because I try to manage my land to be conducive for the spring hunting season/nesting brooding habitat. I've owned it now for 11 years, and every year we've had any where from two-four gobblers show up in mid March along with up to ten hens at one time on game camera. I usually manage to kill one or two turkeys on this farm. Sometimes two year olds and sometimes older birds. Every year, or since I started managing it right, more turkeys would be back.
I think they migrate from northern Giles county when they start splitting up after winter, and there is always a few around my area. That's why I don't feel bad about killing a few.
But manage your place how you want to, and hopefully you have enough land and time to do it without interference from other people.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk