McKenzie has the more realistic looking ones but since joining with Delta, the overall quality has gone down. I shot the ASA Classic this past weekend and we started with brand new targets...by the time we got to the last few targets on a 20 target range, they were shot up really bad...after about 75-100 shots. By the 2nd day after we swapped ranges, the targets took a beating with big holes and hunks of foam missing. Keep in mind they were only shot a max of 200 times....179 to be exact...with bows 288 or less fps and with target points.
Rinehart targets are much better material for shooting but their animals look sort of goofy to me lol. They hold up to hundreds of shots though without wearing bad.