He was a very low scoring deer for his age at 4.5. Far below average for our area, but would still shoot him to this day due to him being mature. What was so special about him was that I was on a 7 year drought of killing a buck and he ended it. I have debated changing the mount for a larger set of antlers, but keep talking myself out of it. What this deer made me to do, was go back to the drawing board and study!
View attachment 147431
This is hard to explain. Not understanding how deer use the terrain was my ultimate weakness. Thinking I did and only hunting stands on certain wind directions is what led to me being unsuccessful. For this deer, I was able to watch him for a while and see how he moved just below the top of the ridge about 20 yards with the wind coming from up above at a quarter-to in the way he was moving. Once he got out of the hardwoods and into the thick clear-cut, how he let his guard down to some degree (akin to deer being much more relaxed when it is dark). Afterwards, I had numerous occasions come to mind of HOW I had gotten busted in the past. Asking WHY he was doing what he was doing and what other bucks had done in the past. WHY did I get busted this time and that time? WHY did this work when similar encounters didn't?
I take notes of all my hunts, so I went back and studied those notes with a terrain map of where I was sitting each sit I had an encounter, the wind direction and the buck's movement (I take notes of where they come from and where they were headed)….for each encounter. I did this for every 3.5 or older buck in my notes that I had seen over the years. I did comparisons of what set-ups worked and what set-ups didn't. Not only specifically where my tree was on the map, but other potential spots along their paths that probably would have worked too. It became clear to me once I mapped all that out. Of course, we all transition as hunters and it took me a couple years to iron out some things. Definitely still have many wrinkles and always will – just keep trying to be better with each hunt. But since then, I have killed 9. Thank goodness for good note taking - never would have had all these experiences.