Seen it time and time again from 10+ years of using trail cams, deer showing up in a location the same day or within a few days of the previous year.
Back in the early 2000s, I had the same buck first appear on cam on my place on the same date three years in a row - Halloween. He would stick around for the rut and then vanish, not to be seen again until the next Halloween. This is how I got started theorizing on annual "rut ranges" that are different than a buck's normal fall range. Later GPS collar studies proved this to be true.I haven't noticed them to the day but i have noticed them to a given time frame. I killed a deer last week that for the last 3 years I've kept up with him he showed at the first week or so of November, he would hang around for a very short time before vanishing again. I notice those types of patterns yearly with certain deer. It's kind of rare that I have one that's just a homebody and he stays on the hunting land but it does occasionally happen.