nitro_z17":1pxsxj0j said:i agree with several points. but i just think butch has peaked. maybe I'm wrong
I'm certainly not saying you are wrong. Butch may have taken them as far as he can take them. If so, I am appreciative of what he has done to turn things around from the dumpster fire he inherited. With a "normal" injury year, 2016 should have given a pretty good indication on whether Butch was going to be contending for championships in the SEC. He had the Vols as the SEC east champs at the start of the fourth quarter of the Vandy game, so the expectations lasted long into the season. I think we all know that even if they had held on that Bama would have boat raced them again, so there wouldn't have been an SEC championship. I really don't see anyone except Bama as the SEC champs until Saban leaves.
Unfortunately, in having to find a new starting QB and replace what he lost to the NFL, I see no way that 2017 is a "championship" type year to really judge his coaching ability. That is why, unless it really turns bad this year, 2018 will be his year to either get it done or not. All bets are off if 2018 isn't a really good year.