Secret Squirrel said:
I wish I could whip out a crystal ball and tell you, but I can't. I have only shot Parker (past 4 years), HCA (12 shots), Whisper Creek (out of business), Headhunters PSE a few times and my bows Mission Menace a few times.
I really need to test some more bow before I can help you out with this. I am looking into getting a new bow after the first of the year 2010.
Whisper Creek is an interesting example. They are out of business per your post (I wasn't aware), but imagine the predicament a shop owner would be in if he sold a bow to someone then couldn't get parts to service it. That would not be good for the shop's credibility, especially in the early stages.
It's a business risk, but if I owned a shop I wouldn't take on smaller lines until the shop was well established and had some growth on it. I would stick to the major lines for a while who are going to do my advertising for me and offer little risk to the shop from a credibility perspective.