Same deer?

[DntBrnDPig]

In 2013 I was getting daily pics of this buck on the left. Then when the season started I didn't get anything until February where he showed up again the same spot. Then a few days ago the buck on the right showed up at a mock scrape I made. His rack is almost identical - do you think its the same buck? The buck on the left (2013) looks to be 3.5 that would make him 5.5 on the right picture but his belly isn't sagging like a 5.5 should. Also what do you think the buck on the right would score?

What do you think?

 

[jm1981]

Both pics look like 3.5 yr old bucks. I think the one on the right would score mid 120s.

 

[cottontown]

LOOKS LIKE THE SAME DEER TO ME

 

[Jon54]

Maybe the buck on the right has been doing sit ups? His neck looks huge.