Sitka Incinerator vs Fanatic

[Gravey]

Anybody tried both with real world feedback? Although I don't hunt in the rain the incinerator is water repellent and says it's the warmest line they have. If you buy the jacket and bibs right now it'll cost $240 more than the fanatic. May not buy either and am hot natured but the older I get I get cold quicker.

 

[Laserman1]

I got fanatic bibs and coat this year. I used to make fun of Sitka but wife convinced me to get some and ive never been warmer. I thought my older cabelas stuff kept me warm but as I get older i kept getting colder. Wore it the last 3 weeks of the season. Only my nose got cold

 

[Mr. Hawk]

I've got the fanatic bibs and jacket as well and I thinks it's plenty warm for TN, I love it BTW.

 

[REN]

I had both, I sold the incinerator because it has to be VERY cold to use those which I didnt find much in TN. Now if you hunted further north or are very cold nature (I generally am) I can fully see the use. I mean it had to be 35 or below for me to even attempt to wear them.

I would have just kept the jacket, that I can use a little more often but the bibs with the jacket was just VERY warm to walk and sit in.

 

[Gravey]

I had both, I sold the incinerator because it has to be VERY cold to use those which I didnt find much in TN. Now if you hunted further north or are very cold nature (I generally am) I can fully see the use. I mean it had to be 35 or below for me to even attempt to wear them.

I would have just kept the jacket, that I can use a little more often but the bibs with the jacket was just VERY warm to walk and sit in.

Regardless of the bibs and jacket I don't walk in them because I'll sweat to death. I ordered the incinerator bibs and jacket as well as a fanatic jacket. The fanatic is so much bulkier and although I like the kangaroo pocket on the front wasn't too keen on the diagonal zip. Could probably get used to it but sent it back and kept the incinerator set. Those teens and low 20's days got me a little this past season and like you say won't use them a ton but maybe won't have as many layers to deal with. Most of the time I'll probably still use the status set. The incinerator pieces were 40% off and then I saw a code for another 10% so half off tempted me too much.

 

[Heath423]

Regardless of the bibs and jacket I don't walk in them because I'll sweat to death. I ordered the incinerator bibs and jacket as well as a fanatic jacket. The fanatic is so much bulkier and although I like the kangaroo pocket on the front wasn't too keen on the diagonal zip. Could probably get used to it but sent it back and kept the incinerator set. Those teens and low 20's days got me a little this past season and like you say won't use them a ton but maybe won't have as many layers to deal with. Most of the time I'll probably still use the status set. The incinerator pieces were 40% off and then I saw a code for another 10% so half off tempted me too much.

Where did you find this deal?
Disregard….I found it

 

[Gravey]

Where did you find this deal?
Disregard….I found it

40% is in their online outlet. At checkout where it asks for additional coupon enter EXTRA10.