Buck 1 last yr in december (night photos). But the reason i know this deer is at least 4.5, is the attached photo from dec 3rd 2020. I had him at 10 yards and he was certainly no 1.5. I was bowhunting for a doe and he was all i saw that afternoon.
Buck 3- had lots of encounters with him. He started tge season fat as mud and ended it poor as a snake. I had him at 3.5 min last yr, possibly 4.5. Here he is mid september 2021. 2nd pic is late december and he was limping badly and very rutted out. Glad he survived
Buck 4- here he is early January. He has a very distinctive forehead shape. I have quite a few photos of him last yr and several this yr. I think he is 4.5 this yr.