• Help Support TNDeer:

Who self-regulates their harvest?

Boll Weevil

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 26, 2011
Messages
3,897
Reaction score
2,595
Location
Hardeman
With all this talk about a declining population, I wonder how many folks will voluntarily stop at 1, 2, or 3 birds vs. killing a limit? Anyone choosing to kill fewer than the limit to perhaps keep another few gobblers to make sure every possible hen has the chance to successfully mate?
 
I kill my limit if I get the chance every year. But I hunt a lot of different spots, public and private, and prefer not to kill more than 1 or 2 toms out of a particular area.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
I haven't killed a bird on my 1200 acre farm in lawrence county since 2012 on purpose. I refuse to hunt what few birds are around. That being said I try to kill my limit every year and do most years but my hunting is spread out over 3 different counties with a couple spots in each county.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
I tend to err on the side of caution on my farm...if it's over hunted that's no ones fault but my own. I know what it's like to not have turkeys to hunt so don't want to go back there again. No problem laying off if I need to.
 
I have several different properties to hunt, and have never taken half off of any on in a year. Last year I didn't get to hunt much, so I only killed two. This year I probably won't kill any for the lack of birds on all of my spots.
 
Along with that term "self-regulate",
how about expanding that to "self-regulating" to only taking high-probability shots?
Some hunters are killing more than they're actually "harvesting".
Just takes a single pellet in an intestine for a turkey to die a few days after it was presumed "missed".
 
There was a time when I simply "limited out" every year.
But at that time, the limit was two birds,
and there always seemed to be plenty surplus longbeards after the season ended.

Geez, we had so many turkeys, TWRA decided to start fall turkey hunting, and increase the spring limit from 2 to 3.

But ever since the limit went to 3, then 4,
I've typically killed one less than the limit (at least "statewide" in TN).
Year before last (which was 2016), I could have easily have killed four 2-yr-old-looking Toms, but did not believe the population (where I was hunting) needed to lose any these young birds. In one instance, I called up what appeared to be a 3-yr-old or older Tom, and would have killed him had he continued "playing the game". I had him dead to rights at 38 yards (easily killed), but he folded up and turned, slowly walking away, refusing to play any more. Easy "kill", but I let him walk.
Simply want it to be "up close & personal", and I eat what I kill, so it also matters to me just how bad a bird is shot up.

I simply don't take anything but head shots, placing a high priority on not getting any pellets in the breast.
Knowing that some other hunters in the area would kill all they could, I chose not to kill any, making 2016 the first year in maybe three decades I didn't kill a turkey.

In 2017, I chose to kill two, giving several others a pass.
Limiting out with 4 in 2017 would have been easy, but it would have taken away opportunity from some other friends who hunt with me, and would have helped guarantee fewer older Toms in 2018.

So far this year, I've given a pass to several jakes, and one 2-yr-old longbeard at about 12 yards.
That doesn't count the two older Toms I "passed" because I let another hunter sitting beside me shoot them.
Last week I killed my first bird for the year (and probably the only one).
This was the 4th longbeard ytd I've had strutting within 30 yards of my gun.

But so far this season, between me and the main person hunting with me,
we have shot 3 times, bagged 3 birds, all head shots, the longest being 28 yards.
The youngest of these three was a 3-year-old bird (1 1/16" spurs),
while the other two were older Toms with 1 1/4" & 1 3/8" spurs.

And as was the case in 2016 and 2017, most of those birds we gave a pass,
end up getting killed by other hunters in the area.
In much of the areas I hunt, all the known living 3-yr-old or older birds are now dead,
as are most of the 2-yr-olds which transitioned from last year's jakes to this year's longbeards.
 
Many are overlooking that turkeys don't limit their range to a farm you hunt,
or another little farm a couple miles away. Several adjoining farms can all be hunting the same turkeys, so that even when some individual hunters are limiting themselves to "one from a farm", most of the longbeards still end up dead by season's end.

I have been fortunate in being able to hunt some relatively large parcels.
It is not uncommon for a Tom to travel a couple miles up a bottom or down a ridge in a single morning.
A couple square miles is 1,280 acres.
How many are hunting farms even a fraction this size?

Also, I see birds often moving several miles (more than two) between the season's opening and the season's closing.

Seeing or not seeing birds on a particular farm may not be a good indication of the larger general area's population.
 
I move on after 1 bird on a property. Nothing I have any closer than a 10 minute drive. I'm not hunting 2 this year because I'm not hearing much this year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Gravey":2ypwkqgj said:
My goal every year is one bird. If I was hunting a place that didn't have the numbers I for sure would not kill 4 even if I could.
X2.
Some years I kill more and some years less. Very few times, in 20 plus years hunting turkeys, have I killed my limit.
 
I try to shoot as many as I can, but I hunt in several different areas and in Alabama and Tennessee.

I don't have a single spot that I think would have enough turkeys to actually shoot four, even if I wanted to.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I do. I have held back this year and it's tough. Even gave one a free pass at LBL because things just didn't work out "perfectly".
Also holding off my home farm this year, might try to take one before season ends.

What amazes me is I know a couple groups of hunters who limit out yearly, I'm talking 20 birds per group. They hunt together and travel around to different farms. Kill out a flock and move on, I guess people like me who opt out to hunt certain flocks simply give the upper hand to these other groups.
Oh well, at least I feel like I tried.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Latest posts

Back
Top