Got my new HSM Bear Loads today. Woo-hoo, can't wait to shoot some.
If I was gonna buy a big bore handgun, I'd buy a large frame .45 Colt before I bought a .44 Mag. With a set of dies of course.A 300 grain plated soft point over 22-24 grains of H110 or W296 makes for a potent 45 Colt load for bears, hogs, or nearly anything.
What gun are you shooting? I shoot a 6" Security Six. I've handloaded some 193 gr. FP GC in it. It's at almost 1200 fps. Never hunted with them though. They would probably shoot clean through most game.
Yes! The 45 Colt has advantages over the 44 magnum. There is a greater bullet selection. It can be loaded to be more powerful than a 44 in the proper gun. It has a greater bullet diameter. It is the perfect revolver cartridge.If I was gonna buy a big bore handgun, I'd buy a large frame .45 Colt before I bought a .44 Mag. With a set of dies of course.
S&W 686+ 4" barrelWhat gun are you shooting? I shoot a 6" Security Six. I've handloaded some 193 gr. FP GC in it. It's at almost 1200 fps. Never hunted with them though. They would probably shoot clean through most game.
Don't know if it's the perfect revolver cartridge but it is the perfect revolver cartridge for meI bought a .45 Colt, but I sold it because I couldn't get ammo, and if I could it usually wasn't at a reasonable price. I can reload now, so I may look at it again simply because it's the real cowboy option.
Provided your .45 Colt can handle modern loads, I don't think there is a wrong choice between 45 Colt and .44 MAG. Either can obtain close to the same results in modern handguns.
However… .357 Mag is hands down the PERFECT revolver cartridge.
At lower case pressure.Yes! The 45 Colt has advantages over the 44 magnum. There is a greater bullet selection. It can be loaded to be more powerful than a 44 in the proper gun. It has a greater bullet diameter. It is the perfect revolver cartridge.
No way I'd go In grizzly country with just a 9 for backup. I may be mistaken when I commented in this thread, but if we're talking bears we're talking grizz.Bears are not tanks, a 9mm will put one down if needed. Recoil with the magnum may be a little much for some people. That said I enjoy shooting my 44 mag pistol a few shots at a time. But I can and do shoot my 9mm alot more.
My comment was directed at black bears in Tennessee.No way I'd go In grizzly country with just a 9 for backup. I may be mistaken when I commented in this thread, but if we're talking bears we're talking grizz.