If she shot first and truly believed it was her deer, I'd have congratulated her and offered help in the recovery. The guy stole that buck. Even if everything he says is true, she shot it first and was searching for it when he claims to have finished it off. No way around it, it's her deer and he stole it.
Yep, he had the perfect chance to teach his son what a good man does! And I'll add he would have had a superb article about ethics and how we can use our skills to help other hunters!
