Jonathan, I just dug out one of the safe queens that might be worth a try. It is a Rem. 870 3" (short, rifle sight smooth barrel with screw in turkey choke) with a 1.5-4.5 scope on it. The scope has the circle and crosshair reticle on it that has really worked well for me over the years.
Why don't you run up here tomorrow and give it a try. It may be the slumpbuster you are looking for. It is a backup to a backup turkey gun, so chances are it won't leave the safe all season.
It was sighted in, but would need to be checked with a shot or two before you hit the woods.
It isn't a "pretty" gun as it has the cloth camo tape butt to muzzle, so there won't be ANY need to be concerned with a scratch. IMO, the 870s were made more to be used and abused than to look at, anyway.
If it works for you, we might be able to work out a deal on the scope after the season, but for now just a loan to a fellow turkey hunter.
615-308-ninesixseventwo.