I really think this deer is just 3.5 IMO and knowing you, I would let him walk. JMO and take him if you want, do what makes you happy, but for sure not over 3.5. I think he will blow up next year!
If he is 3.5 then he is gettting a pass by me, not saying he ain't tempting but if what redheadshooter said is right then I want to see what he does with another year added on, now if he walks past my wife thats a different story, I couldn't blame her a bit though, he is a great buck already, he is definitely dead if he walks onto the hunting club beside us