big bucks are taken every year by novice hunters.....it's just the law of averages, I guess.
I showed , without doubt, that time in the stand is pretty crucial to success in taking larger deer.....anyone that does not hunt all day during the chase and rut phases is not a seriuos deer hunter...imo. The second rut can be just as productive...Midday can be great...!
Unless deer are in feed mode and they are prefrring one certain food source, random sightings are the norm. if they are feeding heavily and not disturbed, you can set a watch by them....even mature deer, so it takes very little effort and skill to kill them...imo.
Killing mature deer in chase mode and during the rut is more luck than most other times....Deer may leave an area completely or simply move so randomly that patterning them is impossible....
At this time, you may only get one chance at a certain buck. If you are not in the stand , then you will not succeed...pretty simple, huh?
I prefer to leave certain areas ALONE until the rut starts.....or at least , until they start chasing abit. I like to keep an area CLEAN until then.....I have seen bucks trying to corral does and push them toward areas they prefer to be. This tells me that bucks know where they are less likely to be disturbed by man and these are the places they want to herd the doe to....If you stay out of certain thickets, deer will gravitate to them when the time is right...Set up a satnd well before the season and stay out of that area until the chasing begins, then sneak in there early and stay all day...I rarely hunt pre-rut, rut and post rut in the same places.
good luck..