• Help Support TNDeer:

Thoughts

O

OakHillHunter

Well-Known Member
TNDeer Supporter
Joined
Jun 4, 2024
Messages
170
Reaction score
220
Location
Parrottsville
I generally don't ask about age and score, but this deer has me generally curious of the age of this buck. I have my thoughts on his age but I'd like to see if that lines up with others. This buck is a product of some management practices we have implemented on our small acre lease. I'll try to upload the video later.
20240920_210556.webp
 

Attachments

  • 1.mp4
    11.7 MB
Last edited:
I wouldn't even dare try aging him from that pic. Needs to be more broadside. But there are some clues. His head to body ratio is pretty big and ear to head ratio pretty big as well. That usually indicates a younger deer, but grainy night pics with infrared lit edges can be deceiving. Still yet I'm going to tentatively guess no older than 3.5yrs until I see a daylight broadside pic that changes my mind.

Furthermore, I don't get excited about antler size until I see bases that equal or surpass ear bases, which is about 4.5"-5". I don't see many P&Y racks with measurements smaller than that. This deer is smaller but likely due to width alone and tine count would reach the 125" P&Y threshold.

If this were the only pic I had I'd tentatively conclude he was a very, very promising young deer that if given safety and nutrition could be world class in time. I say tentatively because with only this one grainy night pic to go by it's really just an experienced guess.
 
Looks like a pretty buck, bad angle to guess an age and score though. I can't tell for sure if he is a 9, looks like it. With no more than that I would guess he is at least 3.5, and conservatively guess a score of low to mid 120's.
 
The video concretes my initial thoughts. He a ginormous 3.5yr old. I mean WOW. Absolutely a trophy as he is but if he could survive another couple years without taking any damage or getting bad sick, he very likely could be record level size.

Almost as impressive is the size of that white oak! No wonder he's there.
 
Ski said:
The video concretes my initial thoughts. He a ginormous 3.5yr old. I mean WOW. Absolutely a trophy as he is but if he could survive another couple years without taking any damage or getting bad sick, he very likely could be record level size.

Almost as impressive is the size of that white oak! No wonder he's there.
Click to expand...
That one has been a good producer. I had a ton of sign around that area last year. The big draw back is its on the property line.
 
Coker said:
He is already a night owl :mad: . Very impressive buck. I would agree with SKI at 3.5yrs old.
What part of TN?
Click to expand...
The mountains of east tn. At the time of this video it would still be legal shooting light. I'm pretty certain they are bedding within 150 yards of this spot. I have gotten them at first light, last light. I have a group that has this 10, a really nice 8 and some small er bucks in it.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top