CrossVolle
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 30, 2017
- Messages
- 600
- Reaction score
- 660
I don't do it either for that reason. But if anyone felt inclined to do so it's their money and it's still practical either way.
-
Help Support TNDeer:
baiting in Tennessee
- Thread starter diamond hunter
- Start date
Pilchard, you guys are making more of this than it is. Obviously you can be a fantastically successful hunter and never use corn. I simply but correctly (using the commonly accepted definition of "Bait") made the point that whether in fishing or hunting, the bait serves the exact same purpose... to attract wild game. Don't go Nancy Pelosi or Chuck Shumer on me and put words in my mouth... man it's gotta be hard to be like you!!!
Squeaky wheels get greased.
If you aren't getting a response from your local officer, call into the Regional office and let his Captain know that you aren't happy with the lack of response.
If that doesn't do the trick, bump it on up to the Regional Major over the region's law enforcement.
Still not seeing what you need? The Colonel over the Boating and Law Enforcement Div. is now over all of the law enforcement in the state. Raise a ruckus with him.
If the response is still lacking, contact the Asst. Director over Field Operations. The next step is the Executive Director. And, if they still are blowing you off, go to your Commissioner over your county. I doubt very seriously that it will have to go past the first 2-3 steps.
But, as an aside, just because you haven't seen a green truck out there may not mean it isn't being looked at. A lot of baiting work is done out of personal vehicles or being dropped off by another officer. Having a green truck parked in the area can be the kiss of death in making a case.
It shouldn't happen, but, unfortunately it does for a variety of reasons. That doesn't make it right. EVERYBODY in TWRA has a boss. Sometimes you have to get them involved.
Last edited:
Rakkin6
Well-Known Member
It's just foreign to me. I wouldn't have much of a problem on private land. But not on public land. When I was Bragg I did some hunting in North Carolina on some state forest land. Was up in my treestand and 6 dogs came running through. Guess in parts of NC they run deer with dogs. Now that I am against, talk about being pissed off. Doesn't really matter the hunting in that area of NC sucked. Nothing but sand and pine trees. Republic of Pineland.
Attachments
Pounding your chest by touting a lit degree hardly qualifies your argument. Your debate students would recognize that posturing as defensive desperation. The thing about anonymous internet forums is that you really just don't know with whom you're communicating. Dare I say you're not the only educated person on the board. There sum purdy fart smellers on this here forum
Hurt your feelings huh? You couldn't dispel my position. Words have meanings. Like the folks on the political left have tried to change the meaning of "Vaccine". I have continued to expose to my students what the real and commonly accepted meaning of the word vaccine is. Don't fall for it. Better luck next time Pilchard.
Doesn't matter what my degree is, or others on here. My point is correct. Words have meaning. I won't allow you to attempt to smear or change the accepted meaning of "bait". The fact that some on this thread tried to do that very thing proves my position was correct. Sorry fart smeller boyPounding your chest by touting a lit degree hardly qualifies your argument. Your debate students would recognize that posturing as defensive desperation. The thing about anonymous internet forums is that you really just don't know with whom you're communicating. Dare I say you're not the only educated person on the board. There sum purdy fart smellers on this here forum
!
Is there any truth to the rumor that twra is considering legalized baiting next season? Heard that one a few times the last few days.
Doesn't matter what my degree is, or others on here. My point is correct. Words have meaning. I won't allow you to attempt to smear or change the accepted meaning of "bait". The fact that some on this thread tried to do that very thing proves my position was correct. Sorry fart smeller boy
If it doesn't matter then why so forcefully inject it into the conversation? And nobody is changing the meaning of words. What we're pointing out is that in this situation there are two distinctly different applications of the same word, albeit similar, and application dictates meaning. You're hung up at arguing a very basic semantic while we're attempting to push you along to where the deer hunting conversation is taking place. This is after all a deer hunting forum, not a campus debate club or pinkies up tea & tofu social.
Here's a paper that delves deep into this exact situation. Since you clearly can't accept that anybody here knows our language as sufficiently as you do, perhaps you'll give credence to Stanford University? https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/word-meaning/
In debate, you never leave your original argument or point, especially when it is correct.
I'll accept your point that application matters, but in this discussion it does not change anything.
Bait: noun -
something used to lure or attract fish or other animals into danger so they can be trapped or killed
Once again my point is correct.
You know you really have driven the point home to your opponent when they attempt to steer you to some other source as you have done.
Ski, you never did participate in debate in high school or college did you?
It's ok if you did not.
I did not study or major in Bio-Chemistry.
My wife did, I would never debate or discuss that specific topic with her as if I was an expert.
Don't get your feelings hurt,
TheLBLman
Well-Known Member
I'm surprised no one has brought up how pit bulls quickly learn to lay in wait near deer feeders.
A fawn or young deer is just no match for a pit bull.
A fawn or young deer is just no match for a pit bull.
TNCharlie
Well-Known Member
Side note: I had ROTC summer camp at Bragg. (Long time ago - 1968). At our orientation we were told that there are four kinds of poisonous snakes and three kinds of poisonous plants in North America and all seven of them live on Ft. Bragg. Not sure about the scientific accuracy of that but the living in Bragg part is believable if not true. That kind of stuff can get into your head when you are learning night patrol.
Rakkin6
Well-Known Member
I did 90% of my stuff on Camp MacKall not Bragg proper. I was only out there 16 months for the Q Course. I know that MacKall has some really nasty draws on it. I think they are worse than the ones on Benning. They didn't really warn us about it to much. I do know they have these two big spiders out there the banana and zipper. The zipper spider is the one with the web that looks like a zipper and the banana is the picture with the hand in it. I ate so many of their webs out on MacKall during Small Unit Tactics, SERE and Land Nav.Side note: I had ROTC summer camp at Bragg. (Long time ago - 1968). At our orientation we were told that there are four kinds of poisonous snakes and three kinds of poisonous plants in North America and all seven of them live on Ft. Bragg. Not sure about the scientific accuracy of that but the living in Bragg part is believable if not true. That kind of stuff can get into your head when you are learning night patrol.
Attachments
Yes you hurt my feelings. I am taking this very personal
I'm not sure how I'll carry on.If you read back through our interactions I stated my position and your reactions have been:
- Telling me I use terrible logic
- Saying to read a dictionary
- Saying I appear uneducated
- Telling us you have a big fishing rod and that you use it to destroy vaginas
- Citing your authority due to your degree
- Never once intelligently reacting to the explaination of my thinking other than saying you're a debate expert
One last genuine question and then I'll be done out of respect for the actual conversation happening in this thread:
If bait is the same thing in hunting and fishing, why can you be successful without bait in hunting but it is a requirement to have a successful day of fishing?
Everyone should know by now that planting a small plot especially a fall plot that greens up and stays green into December or later is used for one thing. To draw deer to that area and then shoot them. Same as corn pile. The perceived benefit to the wildlife is irrelevant and doesn't change the purpose of the plot.
Ding, Ding, Ding....
they shall beat their swords into plowshares
From a CWD standpoint, I don't think baiting is a good idea. From my own personal opinion and take on methods, it's just not for me.
I honestly don't think it'd affect me much if allowed. I make a habit of cutting open the stomachs of most deer I kill on the farm, and most all will have corn in them, so my guess is some other hunters around me are already doing it, or more than likely it's people who have feeders set up in backyards for wildlife viewing.
I'm just gonna keep on doing what I do, which is hunt the hardest during the month of November, ignore most sign I see and focus on terrain features and sanctuaries and keep my fingers crossed.
If someone feels like they need bait to make them a better hunter, and it's legal, well I guess that's their business.
I honestly don't think it'd affect me much if allowed. I make a habit of cutting open the stomachs of most deer I kill on the farm, and most all will have corn in them, so my guess is some other hunters around me are already doing it, or more than likely it's people who have feeders set up in backyards for wildlife viewing.
I'm just gonna keep on doing what I do, which is hunt the hardest during the month of November, ignore most sign I see and focus on terrain features and sanctuaries and keep my fingers crossed.
If someone feels like they need bait to make them a better hunter, and it's legal, well I guess that's their business.
