Well, I have only killed one long beard. I never hunted turkey until a few years ago. With that being said, I went to LBL last year by myself. I figured I would learn by trial and error. I roosted some birds the evening before the opening day. Went in early the next morning and got settled in real close. I heard the birds pitch down, so I hit the slate call a few times. Birds were gobbling before I even finished. Within a few minutes here they came. 3 jakes. One was larger (super jake) gobbling just like a long beard. Came to within 25 yards and I decided to let them walk. If I had it to do over again, I would have smoked the big one. I roosted them, called them in and should have killed one. So my answer is YES, I will kill a jake. I don't have enough under my belt yet.