Another vote for primal. I have the 22' Mac daddy and it's very comfy. They also have jaws that wrap around the tree and hold the stand in place while you put a strap/chain on. I found that to be a nice safety feature.
I'm not sure but they absolutely came from the same manufacturer. Of the 3, the X-stand is best in my opinion.I've noticed that the Muddy, Big Game, and now X-Stand are all basically the same stand. I wonder who actually manufactures these?
Except neither the Big Game nor X-Stand have the lumbar support feature the Muddy does. Absolutely critical in my opinion (for us old guys).I'm not sure but they absolutely came from the same manufacturer. Of the 3, the X-stand is best in my opinion.
I really like the X-Stand "The Duke." It's a 20-foot stand that's rock solid, comfortable and has a shooting rail. The best part is the "Jaw Safety System" it uses to secure it to the tree. If you are putting it up by yourself, this system is a must.
I have both the Muddy and Big Game stands and they are the exact same stand except this one has the system that lets you secure it to the tree before climbing.
It's $199 on Amazon right now:
Amazon product ASIN B00VJUTA9C
String Music: I have been looking at getting one of these. Most reviews Ive read are 4 or 5, but as with anything, there's always a few who complain and give it a 1. Most of the 1 score folks complaints are that the stand is noisy. Have you found that to be the case? Any cons you can share?
I just bought a 1.5 Big Game at Sportsman Warehouse this week. They are on sale for $143. I like the mesh seat and the extra space in the 1.5 without having to go to a buddy stand.I like the 1.5 Big Game, also I put a chain fairly loosely around the tree just incase ratchet strap breaks
Did he get the buck?I've got ladder stand that have been up year-round for 20 years. Straps break!
I try to get around to every stand every year and check the condition of all straps, but sometimes wear can't be easily seen. Although I'm not as concerned with 2-person ladders, as they all have to two ratchet straps, but the single-person ladders with single straps are a concern. Had a strap break on a single-person ladder just as a hunter was lining up a shot on a nice buck. Luckily, ladder didn't fall. But was a pretty scary experience for the hunter when the ladder seat suddenly dropped a foot just as he was raising his gun.
one over the other? ThanksI have the millenium 110 and the Xstand Duke .
Both are right at 20' or so. Both have the mesh fold up seat , i would look at both of these . They are around $250 ea. Good luck
Nope, the sound of the stand sliding down the tree sent the buck running.Did he get the buck?
I would buy the X stand but either will fit the bill and last for yearsone over the other? Thanks
My thoughts exactly. I like having the cable lock around the tree due to it being more weather- and critter-resistant. It's easy to check the strap for damage with it being right in front of the ladder. Peace of mind goes a long ways when climbing a stand in the dark.Just purchased an X Stand "The Duke" last week. I got it put up yesterday with a little help from the wife. The most stable and safest ladder stand i've ever owned. Whoever designed it knew what they were doing and I suspect they were a hunter.
Three points that fasten it to the tree. It has the jaws at the top and another set at around shoulder height that lock it to the tree before you even have to climb up. The third point is a ratchet strap at the top which I think is redundant but strapped it anyway.
Only negative I found is that I wish it had one more ladder section. I like to be 20' from the platform to the ground and the Duke is 20' from the shooting rail to the ground. No biggie, I don't think the deer will notice.
I highly recommend the Duke and plan on replacing all my stands with it in the future,
Makes alot of senseOne advantage with a two-man stand that I have not seen noted is that its extra width allows me to stand and hunt behind the tree easier. I have a couple of spots in particular in which deer occasionally cross behind me; it is easier to stand, peek around the tree, and shoot from either side of the 2-man stand than it is from the 1-man. (Hope this makes sense.)